Coinbase Maturity, Blake2B Miners & a Strategic Hash Reserve | X Space with El Loki & Key and Chain
· 1 h 46 min · 34 chapters
Node runners and miners debate what comes next for Bitcoin after the switch from SHA-256 to Blake2B and the 180-day rolling coinbase maturity (CBM).
Topics include whether old ASICs can mine Blake2B, stacking proof-of-work algorithms, Stratum V1 failover endpoints and DATUM, removing OP_RETURN, nodes on phones, PR 476 (permanent one-year rolling coinbase maturity) vs. the 180-day compromise, the fixed supply of Blake2B ASICs, a "strategic hash rate reserve" to counter 51% attacks, and building a separate node implementation.
Can existing ASICs mine the new algorithm?
The speakers discuss whether hardware like the KD Box Pro can mine Blake2B. Someone else reported that it didn't work for them, and it ended up as a space heater. One speaker expects the convertible machines to be identified within about two weeks. Another disagrees and thinks the information will trickle out slowly. They explain that ASICs are not general-purpose computers. A chip either has Blake2B circuitry (some dual-mode chips do Blake2B and Blake2S) or it doesn't. Getting a SHA-256 ASIC to compute Blake2B might be possible in theory, but it would be slower than mining on a laptop CPU.
The "crackhead" proof-of-work idea: stacking algorithms
After the network moved from SHA-256 to Blake2B, JD suggests a different approach for the next time hash rate ends up in the wrong hands. Instead of replacing the algorithm, the network would add a second one on top: a block's hash would have to pass through Blake2B and then another algorithm. That would keep the existing security while diluting the influence of whoever dominates one algorithm. Others raise two objections: insiders could collude to pick the next algorithm, and it adds overhead for small miners. JD sees the extra friction as a positive. In his view, mining that is barely profitable attracts people who care, and the ideal algorithm would only support hobbyist "Bitaxe-style" devices, not industrial miners.
Another idea: mining to transact
One speaker floats making every transaction require a small proof-of-work, so that every node mines a little. The others agree it is "potentially problematic."
El Loki on next steps after the 180-day coinbase maturity (CBM) change
Asked what should come next, and whether RDTS should become permanent, El Loki says:
- **His top priority is Stratum V1 failover endpoints.** Most major pools now use DATUM, so the "blind hashing" attack the change targeted has largely been mitigated. Failover endpoints should only be used for real DATUM failures, not as a way to blind-hash without doing template work. He calls Lazarus Pool's handling the ideal model and trusts the pool operators to enforce this.
- **On permanent RDTS and future CBM**, he says it's uncharted territory and too early to conclude.
- **He would support removing OP_RETURN entirely**, calling it a liability. He wants small block space so nodes can eventually run on phones, which in his view drives adoption and use as money.
- He admits he doesn't know much about Lightning. He thinks extending coinbase maturity further should be the priority, and says he's mentally drained from reviewing PRs.
Leadership, transparency and "shedding the skin"
The host praises El Loki's focus on running nodes on phones. He warns that miners with different values could undermine that goal, as happened on SHA-256: they had expected BIP-110 to activate without a URSF, it didn't, and they realized they had "lost this war years ago." He argues the burden should be on miners to prove good actors are in control. Despite valuing privacy, he believes miners who care should identify themselves, at least pseudonymously. In his view every movement has leaders, so the right people should take the seats rather than leave them to figures like Michael Saylor. He calls Bitcoin a snake that must shed its skin and counts the move to Blake2B as one shedding. He admits that deliberately colluding to cut out uncommitted miners would have protected the network more, and asks when they would be willing to "do bad to accomplish good."
Agency and adoption
El Loki says withholding miner payouts was already a radical but justified use of node-runner power. Running a node gives people agency, and expensive hardware (a 2 TB SSD, a $900 Start9 server) is a barrier. Most people won't seek that agency until things get dire, so the chain should be ready to onboard them during the "fourth turning." He also names Stratum V1 as a deeper root problem.
"Suicidal empathy at a technical level"
The host argues that Bitcoin is an idea and could even be rebuilt from scratch. He would currently limit accessibility to protect the protocol, arguing that on SHA-256 Bitcoin grew too popular with people who didn't share its values. Choosing an algorithm openly let anyone buy the matching miners, which left the group on the back foot over who controls hash rate.
Why not go back to 100 blocks
El Loki stresses careful, "calculated" mistakes and an empirical approach. Withholding payment made miners listen. Reverting to 100-block maturity would pay miners immediately and bring back the conditions that "spam coin" created. He rejects the claim that a long maturity is "proof of stake."
[00:26:49 – end] Can coinbase maturity be too long?
The host notes that the harms of a short maturity are easy to see, but it's hard to name concrete harms from a very long one beyond discouraging mining. He floats a 20-year maturity: about 1% of the supply is left to mine, but transactions need processing forever, so he wants the people who choose to treat them fairly to be the ones doing it. El Loki says he increasingly sees this view, though the effects of widening that divide are unknown. The host adds that such a long maturity would kill industrial mining economics, since nobody could expect a return on investment. The only demand left would be hobbyists who like a small, 3D-printable miner. The transcript cuts off there.
Hobbyist miners, and BlackRock as a comparison
The host goes on with the 20-year maturity idea. Small, low-power hobbyist miners would be fine even if total hash rate stayed small, since nobody would fund industrial R&D when the payoff is so uncertain and far away. He then compares this to BlackRock: if it abandons the XBT held in IBIT, which he assumes it would be legally obliged to do, it would waste more XBT than even a 100-year maturity would.
El Loki: agnostic on very long maturity
El Loki notes that the UTXO set was inherited from the Genesis block. A very long maturity could push dormant or replay-protected coins, including government coins said to be replay-protecting their transactions, to act. Those holders could become "sitting ducks" while they try to organize an attack. He wouldn't oppose such a proposal but calls himself agnostic, a "fence-sitter." The host's view is that it's easier to select for people with the right psychology than to instill it.
A guest's case for a four-year minimum
A guest admits he goes back and forth on very long maturity but keeps coming back to one point. Even Michael Saylor tells people to hold for at least four years. Requiring the people with write access to "the most important database in the universe" to stay in for four years only seems radical because everyone is used to 100-block maturity.
El Loki on the "strategic hash reserve" and nodes on phones
El Loki has watched the host's video on a "strategic hash reserve." He finds it interesting but doesn't think now is the time. His focus is still on more nodes, so that more people can discover their own agency. He warns against the "remnant of the remnant" assuming only they can understand, and expects that as chain growth slows, technology will make self-custody easier. Asked whether a pruned node could already run on a phone, he says yes, but stresses that some people still need to fully verify the chain back to Genesis. The host counters that nodes are tools for personal verification ("the book that never lies to you") but don't enforce rules without hash rate behind them. El Loki agrees, saying BIP-110 was a "hard awakening" when a handful of pools ignored it. He endorses Key and Chain's comparison of hash rate to guns: it's the force behind the rules.
Why great things decay
The host uses the United States as an example: something built at great cost lost gold backing, entered endless wars and declined. He argues the cause is that good people grow old and die and aren't always replaced. In mining, committed miners leave or get diluted by "hash rate immigration" from people who are only in it for profit. He says Bitcoin needs a defense against the force that "defeated all empires."
Families as a model
El Loki says he needs time to process all this. The host suggests powerful families as a model for something that outlives empires. They cooperate, often in secret, keep their own rules, cut off members who stray, and are not democracies in which the children can outvote the parents.
Spam coin as a "beta test"
El Loki calls the conversation a "metamorphosis" for him. He fully agrees that the priority now is high agency and getting mining rigs away from people who don't show it. He describes spam coin as a beta test the community fell short on. He also argues that early choices still limit them: Luke Dashjr opposed Stratum V1 (SV1) from the start, but the community "chickened out." Even so, he thinks they've built a decent foundation.
"Good enough isn't good enough"
The host suggests El Loki's unease comes from the fact that what they have is far better than anything else but not the best imaginable. He argues that winning is the highest form of agency. If miners are getting what they want, writing them off as apathetic is a mistake: if you can't move an obstacle, you're losing. He asks tired figures such as Mechanic not to grow weary of serious questioners, and warns that settling for "good enough" is what produced the mindset that "everything's good for Bitcoin."
Eternal vigilance
El Loki pushes back that chasing perfect solutions often fails. BIP-110 couldn't eliminate spam but mitigated it well enough, especially the CSAM threat, and new filters now target new spam. He doesn't believe people are inherently good: someone will always try to graffiti the stained glass of a cathedral, so the defense is eternal vigilance against complacency. He adds that the community has shown resilience and can "crush the enemy," which in this case means blind SV1 hashers and rig owners who don't understand the effort.
Clarifying "good enough" and relieving fatigued leaders
The host clarifies what he meant. Decisions obviously have to be made, but systematic "Bitcoin cyber hornets" tend to assume nothing exists between the options on the table, when the possibilities are endless. Once you measure something, adversaries know where you're looking. He compares a team to musket lines: tired shooters should step back so the next loaded rank can step forward. He says he has stopped trying to convince people and will "seize the power" needed to build defenses. He also welcomes Discord engagement that takes leaders off their pedestals, since piling every question onto tired leaders only tires them further.
Never outsource your thinking
El Loki agrees. Consensus among everyone in the community decides where the network goes, and people should never outsource their thinking to him or anyone else. He supports people staying adversarial with figures like AlphaMind: AlphaMind seems to be listening, but that's no reason to become complacent and forget what happened.
[00:57:24 – end] Original ideas and PR 476
The host says he doesn't record his own Spaces and takes week-long breaks from others' content to protect his independent thinking. In his view, the "marketplace of ideas" means bringing your own idea, not choosing from what's already on offer. He was frustrated when his idea of a one-year rolling maturity was immediately lumped in with "PR 476." El Loki says he reviewed every PR, tried to make the case for each, and gives PR 476 a "concept ACK." He explains that it proposes a permanent one-year rolling coinbase maturity, independent of RDTS. Unlike Fly the Elephant's PRs, it doesn't retroactively change whether existing UTXOs can be spent, which is why he likes that it looks beyond RDTS to the future. The transcript ends there.
Consensus on PR 476 and the risk of a split
El Loki returns to PR 476. He liked that the people backing it were thinking beyond RDTS expiry to the long-term effects of extending coinbase maturity, and he urges people to read the PRs on GitHub and think for themselves. The trade-off is that anyone can follow a hard fork, but you lose everyone who doesn't, and that could be a large share of hash rate. He notes that supporters of PR 468 saw no precedent for going to one year. He calls himself mostly unbiased and fine with withholding miner payment indefinitely to move equipment to plebs, but admits a habit of going along with the crowd and finding momentum hard to resist.
Key and Chain: "We are going to win"
Key and Chain says that, although many are tired (he was worn out just watching Luke, Mechanic and Cratter argue before BIP-110 activated), they will win. The word "agency" feels heavy only until you find your role, and then it feels good. In his view BIP-110 showed that "fake Bitcoiners" effectively sold their coins through replay protection without realizing it. There turned out to be more of them than expected, but the community "took everybody" in a brain drain, apart from Joe Nakamoto, as someone jokes.
Encouragement for El Loki
The host says he looks forward to the moment El Loki becomes convinced of a path, because real force will follow. He compares it to finding the right spouse: "you don't know it till you know it." Someone adds, "babies are gestated in the dark."
Centralization and naive miners
El Loki notes that the debate had little time to get going. From outside, it looks centralized in who calls the shots. He doesn't expect that to last, since more participants would add too much overhead, but he's concerned about the small number of people making consensus changes compared with everyone else. He sees owners of mining equipment as naive, following along just to get paid, and calls that a current and future attack vector.
Extended coinbase maturity as an "ace in the hole"
Not going to one year now doesn't close the door, since update 29.4.3 still allows it later. El Loki sees no new Blake2B ASICs being made under the 180-day rolling maturity and cites a Sam Wagner video about a manufacturer put off by it. Asked what would make him extend it, he names a clear reorg attempt or a group approaching 51%, and sees it for now as an emergency measure, though possibly something beyond RDTS. The host replies that acting early and being wrong does little harm, and he doesn't want to "wait to get shot at first."
The strategic hash rate reserve
The host splits the roles: coinbase maturity moves hardware between owners, while a strategic hash rate reserve would counter 51% attacks, and both need incentives. The group gets excited about plebs running hashers at 50% and ramping to 100% when an attack comes, rather than changing code. They call it great for morale. The host notes that Blake2B ASIC supply is effectively fixed right now, which makes this a special moment. He argues that the money should be fair to everyone, enemies included, but that hash rate and rule-setting are a battleground where enemies don't need to be treated fairly. He says he has a financially incentivized design for the reserve but wants to sleep on it before sharing.
Thinkers versus talkers
They joke about their "crackhead ideas." El Loki links Bitcoiners to introverted, judging personality types and says withdrawing to think helps him, though his recent coinbase maturity videos left him drained for a day. The host says he does the opposite: he throws ideas at smart people early, because learning is iterative. That's why he doesn't take it personally when others answer his loose ideas by pointing to specific PRs. El Loki calls himself a contemplator rather than an executor.
El Loki's position: 180 days first, one year possible
Nothing blocks extending maturity if enough nodes and miners back it. El Loki thinks it should come after RDTS. If the 180-day rolling maturity doesn't change who owns the miners, one year "absolutely is on the table." He adds that profitability keeps "shitcoin miners" involved, since they mine to sell XBT for fiat, not to secure it. He calls for boycotting the marketplaces to starve those miners while they wait six months for payment, noting that longer maturity has already pushed some to sell. He finds claims that this is "tampering with supply" or "proof of stake" baffling, and says opponents cling to 100 blocks only out of tradition, even though mining in 2009 used ordinary computers rather than ASICs.
The host: fixed supply of Blake2B ASICs
The host argues that the supply of Blake2B ASICs is effectively fixed, so mining XBT will stay very profitable almost regardless of price. The hardware has to be moved now, and a long coinbase maturity is the only tool he sees, though he's open to alternatives. He predicts that six months will look "tame" within a year, and says a four-year maturity is ordinary Bitcoin thinking even by SHA-256 standards.
A separate node implementation
El Loki says extending maturity now probably couldn't happen within Knots. It would need a separate node implementation or a hard fork. The host strongly encourages him to build one. El Loki agrees that several implementations reduce single points of failure. They mention Jason's Knots-based project, which they aren't sure is a full implementation or just a set of filter defaults. El Loki says 20% of nodes running such an implementation with enough miners behind it would be meaningful. He repeats that the debate got boxed into RDTS expiry: PR 476 broke out of that frame, which is why he concept-ACKed it as the way to move miners to plebs at full speed. The 180-day rolling period was a middle ground between that and returning to expiry. The transcript ends there.
Key and Chain: 180 days was a non-decision
Key and Chain says he got involved late and regrets it. He rejects calling 180 days a "middle ground." In his view there's a minimum amount that actually works, and anything less might as well be nothing. He calls 180 days "the thing you do when you don't know what to do." He thinks its main effect was pushing shitcoiners to list rigs on Mining Rig Rentals. That's somewhat positive, because it hands block template construction to the renter, but it isn't optimal. He recalls Mechanic, in a Space, calling one year a "giant headache" for his own mining. To him that's a reason for one year: if it bothers committed miners, it will really hit the others, without stopping dedicated ones like Mechanic. One year has weight. Six months felt like a weakness that miners could wait out, especially framed around RDTS expiry, like workers who stay at a bad job because a raise is always "next year." His analogy is that it takes a certain temperature to cook an egg, and they didn't reach it. The host calls it activation energy.
El Loki recounts how the PRs played out
El Loki thought one year was a given early on. In his account:
- Many people hadn't read the release notes for the original soft fork. Coinbase maturity was extended to about 45 days after activation, creating a September 21 "cliff" when withheld coins would become spendable at the mempool policy level.
- PR 429 would have pushed that cliff out to RDTS expiry, making it far larger than about 20,000 coins, and that was unpopular. The core problem was that there was no rolling maturity, so if the fork expired, everything would revert to 100 blocks.
- Mechanic, admitting he hadn't read the release notes, put up PR 468. Bigfoot's PR 476 for a permanent one-year rolling maturity got pushback, including from "78."
- Fly the Elephant's PR 477 would have given the withheld coins a 45-day rolling maturity. It failed because it retroactively changed the spendability of coins due at block height ~979,919.
- El Loki only took PR 476 seriously after seeing Key and Chain's video. Many wanted one year, but it didn't reach consensus. People felt that jumping from withheld payments to a permanent one-year rule outside RDTS was too much, especially once blind hashers had started using DATUM.
Credit and regret
Key and Chain credits Luis Marcano and Killumbino for coding and testing (ACKing) the one-year PR. Both he and El Loki feel they arrived too late. With more time, they think it could have reached consensus.
Is the current consensus failing?
El Loki doesn't think it's failing. Miners holding rigs for rentals that see little demand may still give up and sell before the six months pass, and Key and Chain agrees: "let it bake." He argues that a permanent one-year change can't be undone, so it needs full buy-in. It also went beyond the soft fork's original purpose of withholding payment from blind hashers who didn't use DATUM. He'll watch the next three to six months. If rigs aren't being sold, longer maturity becomes a real concern and they should be ready. Key and Chain adds that if miners keep renting rigs out instead of running them themselves, that's a signal.
Watching profit-driven miners
El Loki praises Key and Chain for showing Red Panda Mining's mindset in a recent video and says they should study miners who aren't aligned with Bitcoin's ethos. Key and Chain agrees. Red Panda, Rabid Mining and similar miners are checked out and don't care what the community thinks, so they should be watched closely and called out. He says rental activity seems to have cooled. The Blake2B machines are a scarce resource and a liability to the network in the wrong hands, and the community has to work out how to get them.
[01:45:39 – end] Wrap-up
Key and Chain has to leave. He mentions tagging the others in a poll: if something goes wrong, voiding rewards will come up, and the poll suggests support for longer coinbase maturity if the discussion moves that way. El Loki thanks everyone for hosting and drops off too.
Recorded with Rexpaces. Watch on YouTube.